At Misfit Island Cafe, we bring the best parts of a neighborhood Cafe to Sitka, AK, with attentive service and a space that feels just right. Our 4.60-star rating across 29 reviews reflects our commitment to great service and quality and accessible facilities for all visitors.
Popular Items
Frequently ordered and highly recommended items at Misfit Island Cafe
Our Story
Welcome to a place where great food meets warm hospitality. We believe dining is more than just a meal - it's an experience to be savored and shared.
Our kitchen is dedicated to creating dishes that bring people together, using recipes that honor tradition while embracing innovation.
Photos
A glimpse of our restaurant experience
Food & Drinks
House Made - Gluten Free
Lasso shortbread -Ted's Special Recipe in the special Pink Box. Great with coffee, enough to share.
Delicious English muffin topped with a sausage patty and cheddar cheese.
Toasted everything bagel with a smear of locally caught smoked salmon cream cheese
The Adult Grilled Cheese A meltdown of cheesy goodness. Blended mix of cream cheese, shredded cheddar, jalapenos, crispy bacon and green onions. (no substitutions) Grilled to perfection on Texas Toast. Served with a cup of tomato bisque or loaded potato soup.
Delicious BLT sandwich on Texas Toast, garlic butter, and avocado crema with a side of salad or chips -Make it a Fisherman's by adding Smoked Salmon cream cheese spread
Roast Turkey breast, Havarti Cheese, with a Slightly spicy fiesta sauce and green chili strips served on a ciabatta with choice of Salad or chips Gluten free bread available.
Smoked local salmon blended w/ whole mustard, mayo, capers, and spices topped w/cheddar on toasted ciabatta. Melted to perfection with a choice of salad or chips- Gluten Free bread available- (blended - no ingredient substitutions)
Chicken breast, celery, pineapple, grapes, water chestnuts, and slivered almonds. Savory sweetness.
The Viral Tuna Sandwich - A unique take on traditional tuna with a taste of corn, sweet peas, apples, red onion, crispy fried jalapeños, and a dash of wasabi.
Chickpeas, celery, pineapple, grapes, water chestnuts, and slivered almonds. Savory sweetness in a spinach wrap w/side of Chips or salad
Mixed greens/romaine salad w/flaky locally caught smoked coho salmon and housemade lemon dill dressing
Romaine with roasted chicken, housemade Caesar dressing, and parmesan cheese
Locally caught smoked coho salmon blended in a tangy cream cheese spread blend served with hot pita bread.
Cup of delicious roasted and seasoned tomatoes creamed and blended into a tasty bisque. Great paired with any sandwich. or served with a buttered soft breadstick
Baked creamy potato bacon soup with a garlic buttered toasted pita
Spring mix side salad with tomato and shaved parmesan served with Balsamic Viniagrette
A mildly sweet chocolate and peanut butter sourdough cookie topped with AK Salt Co Blueberry Sea Salt
Butter croissant, crisped on a griddle press, topped w/cream cheese, & chocolate chips, chocolate syrup, & powdered sugar. choice of bananas, or berries
1 or 2 scoops of premium Vanilla Bean ice cream Add your choice of toppings separately for an additional charge
Warm, apple fritter topped w/icing. - Add baked cinnamon apples & a scoop of premium vanilla bean ice cream
Peanut butter, & grape jelly on an English muffin- served with chips & cookie
Turkey, & cheddar on an English muffin with mayo or mustard- served with chips and cookie
Wild Chaga mushrooms, double espresso & steamed milk
Decaf Superfood Hot Chocolate made- Organic: Peruvian Cacao, Reishi Mushroom, Coconut Sugar & Monk Fruit Sweetener
Japanese Ceremonial Grade Matcha, Wild Chagga mushroom, Organic: Cacao & Ceylon, Cinnamon & Monk Fruit
Premium bovine collagen peptides, coconut sugar, ashwagandha, lion’s mane extract, vanilla bean—supports glowing skin, strong hair, and healthy nails.
Vegetarian - Gluten & Dairy Free blend- Made with whole milk, request dairy-free option
Red Cat Barrista Chai with steamed Whole Milk
Caffeinated - Earl Grey, Assam, Green Herbal - Alpine Berry, Jasmine, Peppermint, Chamomile
Double espresso poured over a rich scoop of vanilla bean ice cream, served in a sweet edible cup
Double Shot Espresso with hot water,
Double Espresso, foamy steamed milk
Doppio (Double Espresso)
Foamy Steamed Milk with Chocolate - Milk chocolate or white chocolate, Kids size available
Double Espresso, Steamed Milk
Foamy Steamed Milk with Chocolate - Milk chocolate or white chocolate
Foamy Steamed Milk with Flavored Syrup
Hear from our valued guests
Great stop in Sitka , Tuna Wrap is the best you’ve ever had.
Great food and coffee! The staff extended great hospitality to our family as well. Save room for the cookies! Yummy! Great partnership with with Bumble Tours too.
Came in with friends for coffee before a tour and we were happy to see gluten-free and dairy free options! Coffee was great and the tours were INCREDIBLE, don't miss this in Sitka!
Just got the jalapeno popper melt down, it's amazing how something so simple can give you so much comfort. It was delicious
I arrived in Sitka a few days ago, and the Misfit Island Café has quickly become my favorite spot! Starting my day with a delicious cup of coffee, a blueberry lemon gluten-free scone, and a warm smile is pure heaven. After hiking, shopping, or enjoying a tour (Bumble Expeditions is the best),a warm bowl of creamy potato soup, pita bread, and a sandwich hits the spot. My top picks are Papa Dave’s Fave (roasted turkey and Gouda with a hint of spice) and Sara’s Salmon Melt (smoked Alaskan salmon and melted cheddar). The best part is they treat you like family which goes a long way when traveling.
Wonderful little lunch and coffee spot just a few blocks from where our cruise ship bus dropped us off. Friendly staff, clean and fast! Don't pass it up if you're looking for a nice place to rest and eat.
Visited Misfit Island cafe on July 17 2025. All staff were super helpful and very friendly. Coffee was great but the gluten free pastry was outstanding, and the cookie with chocolate chip and alaskan sea salt was sublime! Highly recommended.
We visited Sitka in May and as a self-confessed "foodie" (and also to complicate matters a coeliac), I was apprehensive about the options in town. Over the course of 5 days there, we ate in many places and this place by far stood out for a few reasons. Firstly, the staff were so friendly not just about our order etc but generally chatting with customers and generating a welcoming feel where it was easy to interact with others without it feeling awkward at all. This led to us getting some great insider travel tips from both staff and other costumers who were happy to join in the general friendliness. Secondly; proper good coffee! Simple as that. Third and most importantly; the food! We absolutely devoured our breakfast. I was delighted that the home-made fresh baked blueberry lemon scones were actually gluten free. So was the oat milk! (Coeliacs...you get it!) We ended up returning here 3 more times and it became our go-to meeting point and our re-set & re-charge point of comfort after some intense days hiking.
Absolutely a hidden gem in the busy Sitka community. Tourists are missing out. I walked Main Street looking for a place to eat a peaceful lunch. If you’re looking for a decent meal without all the hustle and bustle then this is your the right spot. The menu is fantastic. The chicken salad wrap is the best I’ve ever had. Nice fresh ingredients. It was so good I ordered a second. Heck, even a little boy saw me eating and told his grandma “I want what he’s having”. Smart boy! The ice cream , two scoops, with all the fixings was spectacular. Don’t miss it! I shouldn’t have eaten it, but what the hell, I was on vacation. The owner is a very friendly lady. We sat and chatted about the area and how she and her husband made Sitka home. The staff is a great team. The owner also runs Bumble Expeditions. I wish I’d have known of the establishment before hand. If you’re looking for a professional and personal tour guide this is the place to book. Saw them work with several visitors to tailor their Sitka experience and ensure it was memorable. Don’t miss Misfit Island Cafe and Bumble Expeditions.
This place is absolute wonderful for food and excursions. You will not be disappointed. We paid more in Juneau but happier with everything in Sitka. Great customer service that is hard to find this day and time!!! We were looking for something to do in Sitka while on a cruise and reached out to bumble excursions. I called and had to leave a message and Sara actually called back. We talked for literally an hour about EVERYTHING. She IS Wonderful!! Brett and Cole did a fabulous job taking us on a land and water excursion of Sitka. Love to go back because of This wonderful company. Sara is fantastic!! Can’t say enough how wonderful misfit cafe and bumble excursions were!
Common questions about Misfit Island Cafe
Misfit Island Cafe is located at 315 Lincoln St #112, Sitka, AK 99835, United States, Sitka, AK, United States.
You can reach Misfit Island Cafe by calling +1 877-784-9226.
Misfit Island Cafe has a rating of 4.6 out of 5 based on 29 customer reviews.
Misfit Island Cafe features the following accessibility: Wheelchair-accessible car park, Wheelchair-accessible entrance, Wheelchair-accessible seating, Wheelchair-accessible toilet.
Misfit Island Cafe features the following from the business: Identifies as women-owned.
Misfit Island Cafe features the following service options: Outdoor seating, Kerbside pickup, On-site services, Takeaway, Dine-in, Delivery.
Misfit Island Cafe features the following offerings: Coffee, Comfort food, Organic dishes, Prepared foods, Small plates, Vegetarian options.
Misfit Island Cafe features the following dining options: Breakfast, Lunch, Dessert, Seating.
Misfit Island Cafe features the following amenities: Gender-neutral toilets, Restroom, Wi-Fi, Free Wi-Fi.
Misfit Island Cafe features the following crowd: Family friendly, LGBTQ+ friendly, Transgender safe space.
Misfit Island Cafe features the following planning: Accepts reservations.
Misfit Island Cafe features the following payments: Credit cards, Debit cards, NFC mobile payments.
Misfit Island Cafe features the following children: Good for kids, Kids' menu.
Misfit Island Cafe features the following parking: Free parking lot, Free street parking.
Misfit Island Cafe features the following pets: Dogs allowed, Dogs allowed outside.
Business Features
We look forward to welcoming you. Make a reservation or stop by - walk-ins welcome!
Request a table and we'll confirm your booking shortly.
